Hotter: Clarkson or Underwood?

[LiddyRules]

Who's the hottest American Idol Winner?

Kelly Clarkson:
http://www.beautifulhairstyles.com/pictures/kc.jpg

Carrie Underwood:
http://us.tv1.yimg.com/tv.yahoo.com/images/he/photo/tv_pix/fox/american_idol_2005/carrie_underwood/gal_carrieunderwood.jpg

Fantasia Burrino:
http://kabiza.com/images/africa-child72.jpg

[BIV]

Let me help you.
Clarkson:
http://www.mtv.com/news/photos/c/clarkson_retrospective_050824/15.jpg

She also gets me vote.

[BravoSierra]

Kelly Clarkson has that PERFECT chubbiness to her. I love the non-skinny girls.... to an extent obviously. Fuck yeah she got my vote.

[Hudson]

Kelly!!!!
I'd make like an ax and cleave her in 'twain!!!!

[BIV]

Kelly Clarkson has that PERFECT chubbiness to her. I love the non-skinny girls.... to an extent obviously. Fuck yeah she got my vote.
I prefer a skinnier girl, but yeah, she's hot.

Here is more goodness:
Kelly Clarkson
http://i.realone.com/assets/rn/rs/2005/games_installer/Kelly_Clarkson_6_-_portrait_-_Quad_Studios_NYC_12804_large.6879604.jpg
http://www.wlkg.com/music/images/0403_kelly_clarkson_d.jpg
http://www.pasada.net/kelly-clarkson/ini.jpg
http://www.satelitemusical.net/kelly_clarkson_foto5.jpg
http://emmaria.blogg.se/images/kelly_clarkson_091645838.jpg
http://www.mtv.com/news/photos/c/clarkson_kelly/getty_images_flip_041119/11.jpg

Carrie Underwood
http://www.realitytvnet.net/fppictures/carrie-underwood.jpg
http://msnbcmedia.msn.com/j/msnbc/Components/Photos/050527/050527_scoop_underwood_vmed_11a.widec.jpg
http://us.movies1.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/tv_pix/emmys/emmy_awards_arrivals_2005_photos/carrie_underwood/emmys05g2.jpg
http://www.eforu.com/cards/pictures/carrieunderwood/cu20.jpg

[roche]

My vote is that I don't give a shit.

[McDonaldMouth]

'nuff said

http://i14.photobucket.com/albums/a337/McDonaldMouth/4ea_6ad_clarkson_concert5.jpg

[ShooterMcGavin]

Clarkson. I agree with the "perfect chubby" comment. She's not exactly fat, but she's got the baby-fat look that makes her look 14, and don't we all want that?

[icepick3383]

i bet carrie's vag tastes like sunshine.

however, she's too goody-goody for me. Kelly Clarkson for the win! Circle gets a square!

[FreeTheCricket]

Kelly Clarkson has that PERFECT chubbiness to her. I love the non-skinny girls.... to an extent obviously. Fuck yeah she got my vote.

Exactly! No contest.

http://i14.photobucket.com/albums/a337/McDonaldMouth/kc.jpg
http://us.tv1.yimg.com/tv.yahoo.com/images/he/photo/tv_pix/mtv/mtv_video_music_awards_2005_arrivals_photos/kelly_clarkson/vma11.jpg

[Chester'sLiver]

Yeah this is a no brainer, Kelly is the hottest. Carrie is cute but kelly is just yummy.

[GoatAss]

I'm gonna go with Carrie on this one. Although it's a very tough choice. I'd still lick the sweat off of both of their asscracks.

[Mother Shucker]

Clarkson has sure come a long way. She is hot as a mother fucker now, was not the case when she won. Underwood has the nice tits though. At this point I go with Clarkson, but give Underwood a couple years to fix herself up like Clarson did, and I bet you I vote the other way in 2009.

[CM Mark]

I'ld eat the corn out of either of their shit just to see where it came from, but I gotta go with Kelly

[Coffee Diva]

I pretty much have to agree with the status quo on this one: Kelly is just bangariffic, but I sure wouldn't turn down Carrie.

However, under no circumstances do I want to hear either of them sing.

[Earth2murf]

That Carrie chich is a perfect 10 While Kelly is a 6,but i think Kelly takes it up the 'ole dirt road.

[Chester'sLiver]

That Carrie chich is a perfect 10 While Kelly is a 6,but i think Kelly takes it up the 'ole dirt road.
Makes her a 10 in my book.:icon_bigg

Carrie has a wierd look to me, I think Kelly is very sexy. I like a thick girl and that makes Kelly at least a 9 to me. I think she blows Carrie away. And as far as Fantasia goes... Im not into beastiality.

[Sinn Fein]

I'm with the overwhelming majority...

[kloraferm]

same difference

[BLACKIEhugeHANDS]

my vote goes to Kelly, because she wouldn't wear a V is for Vegetarian shirt.

[LickRosco]

Kelly Clarkson is hot...but Blair Underwood is the tits!

[TreeFortRichard]

Who's the hottest American Idol Winner?



Fantasia Burrino:
http://kabiza.com/images/africa-child72.jpg
Brilliant!!!:clap: :clap: :clap: = 3 clappies!

[Milwuakee Cop]

Clarkson, no doubt.

[DeltaPin]

Clarkson

[Smokezilla]

Who's the hottest American Idol Winner?

Fantasia Burrino:
http://kabiza.com/images/africa-child72.jpg

"And the worst part of it is: I NEVER LEARNED TO READ!!!":cry3:

[Mooseman]

As much as I love Carrie, I got to vote Kelly on this one. Kelly is smokin!!!! Carrie is just cute, she's like the girl next door.

[PrncssNikki]

Kelly Clarkson. Carrie's not attractive to me, at all.

[JoeyDVDZ]

Sorry, I gotta vote Nikki.

[GreatAmericanZero]

Fantasia looks like a tranny

[Ploppy]

I'm throwing my vote for Carrie. Kelly seems like she would be kinda bitchy. Carrie seems like the kind of girl that would be happy making her man happy, not to mention she's hot and sings like an angel.

But my favorite:

http://home.insightbb.com/~jlspan/Farina_copy.jpg

[soiled pj's]

Kelly Clarkson is definatly #1 on my want to bone list, but did you guys notice the the peep show holes in fantasia's shirt ?

[Big Dick Mcgee]

As much as I love Carrie, I got to vote Kelly on this one. Kelly is smokin!!!! Carrie is just cute, she's like the girl next door.I voted Carrie because of the girl next door look.She looks innocent enough but you know she's got to be a freak in the sack.

[OnASouth]

carrie's kind of a standard issue blonde, but i'm partial to blondes. so she wins for me. but kelly is definately bangable.

[WoodenPlank]

Fantasia looks like a tranny

Sounds like one, too. She was opening for Kanye West when I went to see him live (In Fantasias home town, to make it worse). Stink on ice doesnt BEGIN to describe it.

Kelly all the way. I completely agree that shes just right; not too skinny, not too big. Actually, I think she can sing. Not my style, but shes got talent. Blame my girlfriend for being a damn music major and teaching me to identify talent. Ugh.

Carrie's okay, definite girl next door, but I wouldnt take her over Kelly.

http://www.satelitemusical.net/kelly_clarkson_foto5.jpg

Hmm...photoshop bait....
"Kelly Clarksons first on-stage sex act...."

*cue car crash*

[Tommy Ceez]

Sorry, I gotta vote Nikki.
:clap:

[LilJimmyRbinson]

Kelly has gotten hotter every year since she's won. She's also the only one who can actually sing. Gotta go with her.

[BillySchwaggles]

Clarkson is a hotter bitch, but Underwood is a much hotter name. I'd punch either in the uteris.

[Shane1V]

Let me help you.
Clarkson:
http://www.mtv.com/news/photos/c/clarkson_retrospective_050824/15.jpg

She also gets me vote.
Thats the best pic of Kelly i've ever seen. NICE.
But Carrie is prettier usually

and Fantasia is the WORST "winner" yet. Did anyone see her on the grammys last year??? Just AWFUL.


::MOD EDIT:: Start Using the EDIT Button or loose your ability to post.

[babehuey_66]

I'm not as good as you guys at this stuff... But I can say that Kelly is FINE! So she gets my vote. Besides, you know that Carrie is a god fearing girl and won't give it up, while Kelly obviously has some serious issues due to her daddy not loving here enough and an old boyfriend really screwing her over. So you knoooooooow she' gonna give it up every time to get your approval. That makes her even hotter...

[bloody poo]

id like to have carrie as my girl and then i would cheat on her with kelly whats up with the white shit around fantasia's mouth does that mean jimmy was here

[Barely Legal]

Kelly and Carrie are both high maintenance. Fantasia on the other hand is just .10 cents a day.

[sinAtra]

Kelly and Carrie are both high maintenance. Fantasia on the other hand is just .10 cents a day.


Low maintenance wins, especially with Kelly trying to out-ego Simon / joust about letting other people do Idol songs. Sure, Carrie may feel like a horse in a feed bag down low, but just give her a little time to let the overproduced circus she's involved in get to her head.

I know who getting my dime . . .

[Boston Funbags]

I like Ruben the best
http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y98/Burkey412/KingKong20051-tm.jpg

[mrhan73]

Who's the hottest American Idol Winner?

Fantasia Burrino:
http://kabiza.com/images/africa-child72.jpg

Very hot!