Court strikes down Indiana land “gift” of $1.2M to Catholic school

Party Rooster

Unleash The Beast
Apr 27, 2005
40,284
7,454
438
The Inland Empire State
#1
I would think the Catholic church would have the cash laying around to be able to afford this on their own. Or at least some kind of land "swap."

Court strikes down South Bend “gift” of $1.2M to religious

Americans United for Separation of Church and State, the Indiana ACLU and the American Civil Liberties Union today hailed a federal court ruling blocking an Indiana city's plan to gift public land to a religious school.

U.S. District Judge Robert L. Miller Jr. agreed with Americans United and the ACLU that the planned land gift would violate the separation of church and state.

Said the Rev. Barry W. Lynn, Americans United executive director, “South Bend officials made a serious constitutional misstep when they voted to use taxpayer money to support a religious school. I’m glad the court put a stop to this ill-considered scheme.”

The three civil liberties groups filed suit after the South Bend Common Council voted 5-4 to spend $1.2 million to buy property that was to be transferred to the Catholic Diocese of Ft. Wayne-South Bend for free. The land would have been used by St. Joseph's High School to build a football stadium.

Such public funding of a religious school violates the church-state separation provisions of the U.S. and Indiana constitutions, the lawsuit charged.

The lawsuit, Wirtz v. City of South Bend, noted that St. Joseph’s High requires all students to receive a Catholic education, including study in theology. All athletic competitions and practices are preceded by prayers consistent with the teachings of the Catholic Church and are led by a priest when one is present. The school handbook encourages coaches to arrange for a prayer service or mass before games when feasible.

Thus, the lawsuit argued, South Bend city funding of St. Joseph’s High unconstitutionally shows governmental preference for one religious institution over others and gives substantial direct support to religious activities.

Said Americans United Senior Litigation Counsel Alex J. Luchenitser, “We’re pleased that the court has halted this planned government handout to a religious institution favored by local officials. South Bend should use its tax revenues in a manner that benefits all its residents, without regard to their religious faiths.”

Said Indiana ACLU Staff Attorney Gavin Rose, "We are delighted that the federal court has recognized that the Constitution prevents government from giving direct subsidies to religious institutions, as South Bend was attempting to do."

Daniel Mach, director of the ACLU Program on Freedom of Religion and Belief, said, "This proposed land transfer is nothing more than a gift to a religious institution by a public entity, which the court rightly concluded is a clear violation of the Constitution."

Plaintiffs in the lawsuit include local taxpayers Roy Wirtz, Eric Brown, Tim DeLaney and Peter Reimers. The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, South Bend Division.

The attorneys representing the plaintiffs are Luchenitser, Rose and Mach, along with Indiana ACLU Legal Director Kenneth J. Falk and Americans United Legal Director Ayesha N. Khan.

http://www.au.org/media/press-releases/archives/2011/09/au-aclu-applaud-court-ruling.html
 

Creasy Bear

gorgeousness and gorgeousity made flesh
Donator
Mar 10, 2006
49,242
37,334
628
In a porn tree
#2
I would think the Catholic church would have the cash laying around to be able to afford this on their own. Or at least some kind of land "swap."
If by "Catholic Church" you mean the Vatican... yes, they have piles of cash, land, gold and treasure laying around. Are they going to share a portion of their loot with some Catholics schools in Indiana? BZZZZZZZT! NOT!

That's not the way it works... the churches feed the Papal beast, not the other way around.
 
Dec 4, 2010
3,596
2
0
Glassboro, NJ
#3
If by "Catholic Church" you mean the Vatican... yes, they have piles of cash, land, gold and treasure laying around. Are they going to share a portion of their loot with some Catholics schools in Indiana? BZZZZZZZT! NOT!

That's not the way it works... the churches feed the Papal beast, not the other way around.
Plus a lot of the riches and loot is being used to fund the retainer. With that many bloody anus' you can't hide them all.