Do you refrigerate your peanut butter?

Do you refrgerate your peanut butter

  • Yes

    Votes: 8 15.7%
  • No

    Votes: 43 84.3%
  • I Hate Peanut Butter

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Sorry, I'm Allergic

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    51

Nothing Sound

Riding the Biggest Wave
Dec 9, 2004
1,808
43
463
Next to aleash
#1
I heard the boys mention this briefly not too long ago, but it was glazed over and never really discussed.
If I remember correctly Opie said that he did not refrigerate his peanut butter and Jimmy said he did.

So what da ya say? Do you or don't you refrigerate your peanut butter? I do not.
 

NuttyJim

Registered User
Feb 18, 2006
14,158
6,435
638
#2
I refrigerate after opening. Then the wife opens the fridge, gets pissed, and puts it back in the cabinet lol.
 
Aug 11, 2005
27,637
4
528
#4
Refrigerating peanut butter is just dumb
 

Josh_R

Registered User
Jan 29, 2005
5,847
458
578
Akron, Ohio
#9
Who the hell refrigerates peanut butter? It gets hard as a rock and rips your bread apart when you try to spread it.
 
Aug 11, 2005
27,637
4
528
#11
I do

I get the kind where the oil separates
Well shit , now we need a thread about Jif and Skippy and all those generic brands

(and how we can kill our enemies that say they're allergic!)
 

samurai

Ridiculum Anserini
May 16, 2007
20,791
4,258
568
Chicago
#12
Who the hell refrigerates peanut butter? It gets hard as a rock and rips your bread apart when you try to spread it.
Me...Never.

My Grandma did. Silly ole' Svenska immigrant Biddy!
 

The Godfather

Spark it up for The Godfather and say!!!!!
May 9, 2007
11,256
10
163
#14
why would you want cold peanut butter?

The grape jelly (or strawberry jam) is already cold.
 
Nov 29, 2006
3,452
374
583
FL
#17
Never.

But I do put opened bags of potato chips in the freezer.... keeps 'em from getting stale. /useless irrelevant information.
 

NoRez

Old, tired warrior woman originally from Antland.
Jun 20, 2008
215
67
373
NY-born Bostonian.
#18
Never.

But I do put opened bags of potato chips in the freezer.... keeps 'em from getting stale. /useless irrelevant information.
You mean you're not supposed to finish them once you open them?

I used to refrigerate a lot more things; my older relatives instilled the fear of everything getting 'buggy' if it wasn't locked up in the 'icebox.' Even now I inspect the peanut butter a little longer than I really need to when I take it out of the pantry...

...a few years ago I bought a plastic container of oatmeal from the little groceria on my corner; it was Quaker Oats only instead of cardboard it was a plastic screw-top container. Left it in the pantry but was never in the mood to make oatmeal, until one cold day months later. Took it out of the pantry, unscrewed the top and started pouring it into the boiling water.... you guys remember Ant's story about the trash bags in his backyard a few weeks' back?

Still can't wash rice out of a pan into the sink without wincing the whole time.
 

maz

TRueWDTer
Feb 16, 2005
64,539
2,103
693
abu dhabi,pa.
#19
Who the hell refrigerates peanut butter? It gets hard as a rock and rips your bread apart when you try to spread it.

Exactly


And Skippy Super Chunk for me

Unless another brand of Chunky is on a real good Sale
 

mills

I'll give em a state, a state of unconsciousness
Jan 30, 2005
13,850
640
628
Flea Bottom
#20
Normally I hate shitty, cakey wonder bread, much prefer the chewy kind, but PB is the one thing I like on it. So no.
 

chumpy

No hopes of repair
Donator
Apr 14, 2004
16,231
1,446
763
Just outside NYC
#21
I now make my own peanut butter. Since it doesn't have any stabilizers in it, I fridge it so it won't separate. Before when I bought it. Jif!!! I left it out.
 

Stig

Making America So Great You Won't Believe It.
Jul 26, 2005
80,987
4,558
623
NH
#22
Why not? Sure, it's cold on my balls, but the dog likes it.
 

distortion9

Satellite Of Hate
Dec 12, 2001
4,925
8
368
NY
#23
Never.

But I do put opened bags of potato chips in the freezer.... keeps 'em from getting stale. /useless irrelevant information.
I have to try this......Emeril swears by frozen Tater Chips.