Gamespot Editor Fired For Honest Review

HumpX

Character Assassin
Joined
Oct 30, 2004
Messages
4,432
Likes
0
Points
261
Location
Rhode Island
#1
Its being reported on several sites at the moment but Penny Arcade has the best summary of what is really happening

Seems the guy gave Kane & Lynch a 6.0 and a video review which pretty much trashes the game. To be honest I never liked his reviews but in this case he was spot-on. Kane & Lynch is an awful piece of shit.......for $60 anyhow.

Anyhow, the big problem was Eidos, the publisher, had spent over 100K on whole-site advertising for the game. Gamespot claimed they had warned him in the past about his "tone" but lets be realistic, they made an example out of him.
 

KakTheInfected

Registered User
Joined
Mar 10, 2005
Messages
1,105
Likes
0
Points
0
#2
Gamespot has probably been caving to publisher pressure for awhile now judging from some of their reviews in the past year. Gerstmann was part of it so fuck him, fuck Eidos and fuck Gamespot/CNet.
 

HumpX

Character Assassin
Joined
Oct 30, 2004
Messages
4,432
Likes
0
Points
261
Location
Rhode Island
#3
Here's an even grimmer post. One of the gamespot guys posted anonymously on a blog and gave an overview of what happened from the inside.

The guy was a 10 year veteran of that site and they locked his office and escorted him out of the building. great way to treat people with dignity. Fucking white collar management people are fucking spineless cunts.
 

ruckstande

Posts mostly from the shitter.
Joined
Apr 2, 2005
Messages
14,808
Likes
4,349
Points
678
Location
South Jersey
#4
Here's an even grimmer post. One of the gamespot guys posted anonymously on a blog and gave an overview of what happened from the inside.

The guy was a 10 year veteran of that site and they locked his office and escorted him out of the building. great way to treat people with dignity. Fucking white collar management people are fucking spineless cunts.
That's not so shocking. That gets done in a lot of corporate offices.
 

BravoSierra

Why do people keep calling me?
Joined
Jun 27, 2005
Messages
3,463
Likes
4
Points
293
Location
Berkeley, CA
#5
This is exactly the reason I never judge a game via game review sites. Reading forums after a release is the best way to do it.
 

Plunkies

Registered User
Joined
Jun 28, 2006
Messages
5,844
Likes
2,583
Points
478
#6
Good job idiots, pick advertisers over readers.

Yahtzee is the only reviewer I trust at this point.
 

HumpX

Character Assassin
Joined
Oct 30, 2004
Messages
4,432
Likes
0
Points
261
Location
Rhode Island
#10
Fuck Gamespot. I havent trusted their reviews since that reviewed Ratchet and Clank.

I agree w/ Bravo Sierra, reading the forums and talking to people is the best way to see if a game is anygood.

Also, I use www.gamerankings.com a lot now, too.
Gamerankings is owned by Gamespot which is owned by CNet.......
 

KakTheInfected

Registered User
Joined
Mar 10, 2005
Messages
1,105
Likes
0
Points
0
#12
Gamerankings is owned by Gamespot which is owned by CNet.......
Gamerankings uses scores from many different websites though. Bullshit Gamespot scores are still in there, but I would assume most are fair.
 
Joined
Sep 10, 2005
Messages
5,668
Likes
77
Points
283
Location
Staten Island, NY
#13
So what If you spent alot on advertising on the site...If your game sucks it sucks...I would never even think twice about playing that turd...even before it got reviewed I knew it was shit. And that fat mess who got fired was honest on most of his reviews...Douchebag or not I trusted his scores.
 

Xyn

3 letters, 0 meaning
Joined
Mar 3, 2005
Messages
3,753
Likes
2
Points
0
Location
California
#14
It's not like game reviewing is scientific. A reviewer gives their opinion and (hopefully) gives their reasoning behind it. You can agree or disagree with their opinions, but they key should be that they stay consistant. Firing a critic for their opinion is just silly.
 

SOS

ONA
Wackbag Staff
Joined
Aug 14, 2000
Messages
48,032
Likes
8,866
Points
938
Location
USA
#15
It is an increasing trend that the reviews are directly tied into bonus to the company that made the game as games have surpassed movies in revenue. If the game does pass a certain mark, the company that made it gets less from the publisher because they have found (this will sound like common sense) that the better the review, the more games will be sold.
 

BIV

I'm Biv Dick Black, the Over Poster.
Joined
Apr 22, 2002
Messages
78,156
Likes
27,219
Points
898
Location
Seattle
#16
Is Gamespot the same guys as Game Informer? I've found that GI is almost always spot on. A couple of months ago I laughed at a scathing review that was right next to an advertisement for the same game.
 

KneeKnee

Trophy Whore.
Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Messages
6,328
Likes
1
Points
0
Location
No kiddin!!!You're from <insert place here>?
#17
Gamerankings uses scores from many different websites though. Bullshit Gamespot scores are still in there, but I would assume most are fair.
Exactly. It shows you a shit load of reviews, if one says 10 and the rest say 5, I know it is a shit game...
 

Blue Heeler

Uber Listener / Asshole
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
15,956
Likes
1
Points
126
Location
KY
#18
They need to fire all of their reviewers, close down the website and burn the building down. Gamespot is biased, corrupt and agenda driven, as someone stated above, once they gave Ratchet & Clank an average review it pissed off anyone that has played the game. Many other mags and review sites gave R&C a 9.5 or a perfect 10. Also, the Uncharted review was a complete backstab...seems if the game has a PS3 Exclusive tag, they drop it a few points.

btw, Chester, go buy/rent Uncharted, it's probably the best PS3 game to date. Naughty Dog did an excellent job.

(You being the world champ of Madden and all...) wakka wakka
 

HumpX

Character Assassin
Joined
Oct 30, 2004
Messages
4,432
Likes
0
Points
261
Location
Rhode Island
#19
More news:

Looks like things are not going well over at Gamespot. The staff are NOT happy campers because not only did their friend and editor get shit-canned for questionable reasons, their long cultivated reputations are tied in with this even though they are just collateral damage. Looks like they are planning a walkout.
 

KakTheInfected

Registered User
Joined
Mar 10, 2005
Messages
1,105
Likes
0
Points
0
#20
Wow, they only gave Uncharted an 8? I haven't played it yet but judging from the other reviews, that really is awful.

But yeah, Gamespot has sucked for a long while now. A 6 for Radiant Dawn? A 9 for Bioshock but a 9.5 for Halo 3? And like I said earlier, Gerstmann was a part of it too so I wish people would stop sympathizing with him so much.
 

KneeKnee

Trophy Whore.
Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Messages
6,328
Likes
1
Points
0
Location
No kiddin!!!You're from <insert place here>?
#21
Wow, they only gave Uncharted an 8? I haven't played it yet but judging from the other reviews, that really is awful.

But yeah, Gamespot has sucked for a long while now. A 6 for Radiant Dawn? A 9 for Bioshock but a 9.5 for Halo 3? And like I said earlier, Gerstmann was a part of it too so I wish people would stop sympathizing with him so much.
Dude, that isnt even the biggest load of shit from them against PS3. Look at their review of Ratchet and Clank.

An overall ranking of just under a 9 and yet, some how, the guy at gamestop gives it a 7.5, the lowest score on the net.

http://www.gamerankings.com/htmlpages2/932369.asp
 

tourettesguy

Certified Labia Inspector
Joined
Oct 4, 2005
Messages
965
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
Akron, OH
#22
Here's an even grimmer post. One of the gamespot guys posted anonymously on a blog and gave an overview of what happened from the inside.

The guy was a 10 year veteran of that site and they locked his office and escorted him out of the building. great way to treat people with dignity. Fucking white collar management people are fucking spineless cunts.
This is why it still boggles my mind why people give two weeks notice anymore when they quit.

I just quit when I feel like quitting, and I leave. Easy. Things aren't how they used to be, so giving two weeks notice anymore is just stupid. Companies will do shit like this as soon as the resignation notice hits the bosses desk. Don't give a company anymore respect than they give you.

Thanks.
 

SKRI

Registered User
Joined
Oct 26, 2007
Messages
216
Likes
0
Points
0
Location
I live in a big rectangle
#23
fired over a video game review thats special.

Kane and Lynch wasn't too bad, it has a great engaging story, pretty fun co-op, and an original multiplayer mode. the frames take a hit and bullet hit detection is sometimes not what it should be, and the games difficulty ramps WAY THE FUCK UP without warning near the end of the game. T'aint Bad T'all
 

sniper

Front, and to the right...
Wackbag Staff
It's My Birthday!
Joined
Oct 13, 2004
Messages
3,850
Likes
0
Points
341
Location
Masshole
#25
Been following this story, it's a shame for the rest of the staff. I never trusted GS anyways, like knee said, I trust forums and rottentomato-like sites and weed through the fluff. This story reminded me a lot of what happened to hexus.net when they gave a bad review of an Alienware laptop and Alienware refused to give them anymore test boxes. That's courting good reviews, what's happening at gs is worse.
 
Top Bottom