So who would have been your choice. Teabow deserved it just because of him becoming the first member of the 20/20 club. Yeah his team loss 3 games, but that just proves once again how tough the SEC is. Although if he didn't win it, I had no problem with it going to either McFadden or Brennan. As for his pro future, I will refrain from commenting on that, at least until the end of Teabow's junior year.
My choice would have been to pack up the trophy and store it in a closet until college football starts getting some good teams back in it and then pick a deserving player to win it. But since they feel the need to award it every year, then I guess Teabow is as good as any other. It just doesn't really matter to most people right now.