US may ban popular Hard Drive imports

burky79

62 75 72 6b 79 37 39
Feb 18, 2005
4,341
0
236
in a house
#1
Hard times for hard drives: US may ban popular imports

----

The International Trade Commission (ITC) has announced that it plans to begin an investigation into several companies that either make or use certain hard drives. In a statement issued yesterday, the ITC said that the hard drives in question are alleged to infringe on patents owned by California residents Steven and Mary Reiber. The two filed a complaint with the ITC in September, saying that the importation of the hard drives violates section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930.

Related StoriesPermanent injunctions getting scarce; patent holders turn to ITC
ITC to bar import of new handsets in patent dustup
President Bush declines to intervene in Qualcomm cell phone patent case
There are currently five companies being investigated by the ITC, including Western Digital, Seagate, Toshiba, Hewlett-Packard, and Dell. All five companies either manufacture drives that use "dissipative ceramic bonding tips," or sell products that use such hard drives. These parts are used to bond electrical wires within the hard drive—while the ITC doesn't specify exactly which patents the technology allegedly infringes on, two patents that are owned by the Reibers, titled "Dissipative ceramic bonding tool tip," appear to fit the description.


rest of story under spoiler tag
Section 337 of the Tariff Act bars the importation of products into the US that infringe on patents owned by others in the US. This is the same stipulation that bit Qualcomm in the butt last June, when the ITC barred the importation of its EVDO chips, circuit board modules, and handsets that infringed on the patents owned by its competitor, Broadcom. At that time, the ITC said that handsets that were already being imported prior to the ruling could continue to be imported, but that no new chips or handsets could be brought into the country.

The Qualcomm ban sparked outrage among the mobile industry, with all of the major carriers—AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon, and Sprint—speaking out against the ITC's decision. Trade group CTIA also criticized the ITC over the decision, saying that it "unnecessarily decreases competition" and would "cause enormous undue harm to tens of millions of American wireless consumers." The same would almost definitely happen if such a ban was placed on products made by some of the most popular hard drive makers in the world.

Even if the ITC ends up ruling against them, Western Digital, Seagate, Toshiba, HP, and Dell might still get lucky if the US Court of Appeals remains on their side, as it did with Qualcomm when the court stayed the ban in September. No target date has been set for completing the investigation, but the ITC has 45 days to settle on one.

----

i dont think this would effect flash media drives... if i am thinking correctly... they dont use ceramic do they?

maybe not. but interesting story anyway.