If Pronger didn't get suspended again he would've gotten it. While Scott Niedermayer is a leader he hasnt been Conn Smythe material. Giguere missed most of the 1st round so he's out, plus he hasn't played as out of his mind as in '03. Then again the only other one to do something like that was Roy in 86. Pahlsson has shut down every major line in the playoffs this year. He deserves it. Give it to a guy that wouldn't normally get it.